Sunday, November 15, 2009

Zach's response to "What Christians Believe"

In the opening paragraphs C.S. Lewis poses a question that I have often pondered and that sets the tone for the rest of the passage. He writes, “If God created the world then why has it gone wrong?” The more I think about my life and about the challenges that I have faced the more I have realized what the answer for me may be.

It was a cold February night; my Mom would be leaving the next day for a buying show. For that reason we decided to celebrate Valentines early by going out for Spaghetti. It was a night much like any other. We were seated quickly; we walked past the old fashioned trolley and were seated near the bar. We placed our orders with quick confidence. We had been there hundreds of times and didn’t even need menus except to pass the time. I had a major English assignment due the next day, we began to discuss it.

“I have to write three letters like the letter between Caesar and Brutus, like in Shakespeare’s play.”

Our salads arrived and we began to eat. Then out of nowhere we began to hear loud pops, like balloons. We all listened intently; although it was not uncommon to have parties at the restaurant these sounds had a different character to them. One, two, three, “Call 9-1-1 he’s go a gun.”

A frenzy of movement, we all dove under the table and sat there like a twisted mess, each grabbing their own phones and placing the desperate calls for help. Another round of pops ensued, followed by a flurry of pops, then silence. Where was the gunman? Was he on the move? Was he coming for me and my family? Thousands of questions raced through my mind. What seemed like hours passed. We sat there, an uncomfortable mess of bodies.

Finally S.W.A.T arrived. Our liberators were finally here. We marched single file hands above our heads, escorted by men with guns. We finally reached safety across the street; it was now ok to breathe. My mom began to cry, as she held my little brother. It was over, it was finally over.

I share this story because I think that it helps illustrate C.S. Lewis’s point. A shooting and killing of innocent people are about as bad as the world can be. But I learned something very valuable from the ordeal. Weeks later, I was driving with my mother and brother, when my little brother of six said something profound.

“Mom,” he began, “You know when we were hiding under the table at Trolley Square? I was praying that Heavenly Father would protect us.”

Wow I thought. I didn’t think to pray, but my little brother who is half my age did. I learned something very important about the power of prayer and about God’s knowledge of each and every one of us. He knows us very personally and is always watching over us.

To answer C.S. Lewis’s question I would say, the world hasn’t gone wrong, rather we face challenges and obstacles, to grow and come closer to God.

8 comments:

  1. I enjoyed reading Lewis's views on agency and comparing them to what we learned in Book of Mormon when we were studying 2 Nephi 2. I was somewhat surprised by how closely the two agreed. As I understand it, there is a dual purpose for evil in the world. The first is that it must exist for us to have agency. There has to be opposition for us to make a choice, and evil is necessary for good. The second reason is, as Zach said, that trials give us an opportunity to learn and grow. I liked the analogy Lewis used of a parent teaching her child to clean up. Giving the child a choice enables him to grow.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This would be a good topic for your personal narrative, Zach.
    :]
    If you ARE using it for your personal narrative, or at least using this as a basis of your narrative, I'd take out "It was a night much like any other" and "It was over, it was finally over." Much too cliche.

    That being said, it was a very good read. C.S. Lewis is probably one of the most quoted nonmembers in the LDS world, and for good reason. I would say, in response to his question, that agency has gone wrong, but since God created agency, nothing is wrong. It's how He made it and expected it to be.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Fascinating blog post. I hadn't thought about Trolley Square for a long time; it's a good reminder of what happened.

    As far as "the world happening" and allowing bad things to happen to good people... Agency hasn't "gone bad." While people make bad decisions, that's something to be expected, especially in a place where we have so much freedom. It's part of the plan, and God knew that agency would be used for good and bad. If there were only good choices, would we still have our agency?

    ReplyDelete
  4. I love the optimistic character of our religion; there is a plan, and justice will be meted.

    It's mostly a matter of language, but I would say that the world has gone wrong, in that it has not chosen the Plan of Happiness. Really, it's very sad. Though the purposes of God will not be frustrated, many people are not living to fill the purpose of their creation.

    To throw in my two cents for other issues commented on here, I say that bad is bad. Bad people do bad things to us and those we love. That's not good. It's bad.

    I have now passed my teenage wisdom on to you. Now I can talk about C.S. Lewis.

    I thought he gave a good treatment of the subject: he contrasts with the atheists , then the Pantheists. Also, I loved the surprise bash-ending!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Agency is simply the ability to CHOOSE between good and evil. Everybody has this choice - nothing in the world can take it away from them. As sad as it is, awful things do happen in this world, and it is also good that it happens or we wouldn't realize the good times for what they are. When people tell me that there must be no God because if there was, nothing bad would ever happen, I only have one thing to say to them. If that is true, then it also means that if there was no God then nothing good would happen either. We would all be in a state of ignorance, just like Lucifer wanted. Something to think about.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I've often heard it said that of all the worlds created by God, Christ came to this one to perform the Atonement. What makes this earth different from all the other earths, and what makes us different from all other children in the universe? It's because our earth possesses Satan's kingdom. God's children on other earths have it easier, for their test is to see what they do with a body. Sure, there are people there who mess up and sin, but that is it. Here, we are faced with a powerful entity who tempts man to intentionally cause pain and suffering. That is why there is so much evil in teh world.

    ReplyDelete
  7. CS Lewis is undoubtably one of my favorite writers. I particularly enjoyed his thought that the fact that religion is complex testifies that it is not designed of man. If it were simple, it would feel like something that mankind devised.

    I would definitely agree with this idea. The world is full of such detail, from a tiny cell to the universe. That such order and complexity could occur just by chance seems ludicrous. To me, the fact that each creation was made according to a pattern and follows rules is a witness to me that God truly created the world. We might not understand everything yet, but if we live righteously someday we will understand all things.

    We like to unlock the secrets of things and categorize them into manageable, understandable groups. The scientific method relies on theories until they can be replaced by greater understanding. In this, we are accepting that our understanding is imperfect, but we are content to live with what we have. Religion is much the same way. Even though we lack a complete understanding of God, we know enough to guide us day by day until we return to Him.

    ReplyDelete
  8. C.S. Lewis is amazing. Can I just say that? I thought that this article was very thought provoking. It made me think about some of the reasons that prove our religion is true. I thought his saying about Earth being enemy occupied territory. I think that it is true. We are among those that are trying there very hardest to take us down. I am the kind of person who likes a challenge. That seems like a challenge to me. I don’t remember who said it, but someone said to live your life in such a way that when you wake up Satan will say, ‘Oh no, she’s awake’. That’s what I want.

    ReplyDelete